YouGen reader Alan Drever lives on the south west coast of Isle of Skye. This part of Scotland has a higher than average lightning incidence, so when considering installation of a solar PV system it was something he wanted to take into consideration.
The risk of lightning strike is not just theoretical: he has had two fax machines knocked out since he moved there in 2003. Yet despite significant sleuthing before starting his solar PV installation he didn’t find any information about potential lightning damage risk to PV. Nothing was mentioned by the Energy Saving Trust (EST) representative (who visited site) or his installer.
Alan had a 4kW solar PV system installed in May 2011. During following winter, an off-grid PV system in SW Skye suffered from lightning strike and the inverter was badly damaged. “This obviously sent alarm bells ringing!,” says Alan. He takes up the story:
Risk and remedy
“I then embarked on what turned out to be an absolute saga trying to get to the bottom of risk level & safeguards!
“First I contacted my installer, who offered to fit an earth spike from the array base into ground. Christmas got in way of acting on this so I decided to consult others. From discussions with EST, SMA (maker of Alan’s Sunnyboy 4000TL inverter) BRE (Building Research Establishment), MCS (microgeneration certification scheme & CAT (the Centre for Alternative Technology).”
What follows is the advice he was given:
EST based its advice on the Accredited Installers Handbook, Photovoltaics in Buildings: Guide to the Installation of PV Systems, which is described as the installers Bible. Apart from being long in tooth (2006 – a new edition is due this month – ed) requirements are not that clear! Installers are required to undertake site by site Risk Assessments (RA). Fitting of an earth spike (from the base of array into the ground) is the only measure specifically cited as common requirement.
SMA stated that surge protection should be installed on DC side (installer did only on AC side). It indicated that varristors in the inverter are designed to protect it against surge damage from lightning strikes nearby, but not direct hits. The inverter warranty cover doesn’t extend to any damage from this (bet house insurance wouldn’t either methinks). So SMA recommends as standard that additional protection is fitted – regardless of the fact that this area experiences higher than UK average lightning frequency & house hillside location. Measures involve surge arrestor fitted on DC side of AC Converter.
Reluctant to engage unpaid.
Advised (via their PV Working Group) that an earth spike could heighten (my italics) lightning risk through potentially increasing strike risk. This has been refuted elsewhere on basis that it’s not what lightning hits that matters, but where it ends up. MCS Working Group were very defensive of the installer.
Advised that an earth spike from base of panel array is required; that it should not have more than 10 ohms resistance; and that it needs to be cross-bonded to mains electrical earth. The sequence of metal parts between panels base & ground (fitment) need to be in a particular order to minimise corrosion risk. Particular issue on west coast obviously.
Despite SMA’s advice & warranty position, Alan’s installer has been reluctant to install the necessary device to protect against DC surges.
In addition to lightning issues, he has experienced problems with system restart failure following power failure due to bad weather.
“With 2 severe storms over Christmas, when I was away, a neighbour found that the PV system failed to restart on both occasions. The cut out device had to be manually switched back on.
“I have surmised (unsurprisingly) that this system should come back on automatically after mains power is restored. CAT had never heard of this happening & reckoned on cut off over-sensitivity. SMA confirmed that system must be set too sensitively, suggesting 30 milli-amp breaker must be involved, when 100 milliamp is sufficient. My installer has been reluctant to substitute the circuit breaker.”
Alan is keen to hear other people’s experiences of solar PV and lightening, and also of any problems or solutions for inverters not coming back on after power failures. Please leave comments below.
Photo: Bo Insogna